Case study

Making effective security decisions for dying prisoners

Research as part of a PhD project in the Department of Sociology is informing how prison staff respond to seriously and terminally ill prisoners by contributing to new guidance on the use of restraints when a prisoner is receiving treatment in hospital.

Clean prison hospital cell.

The issue

The ageing prison population has led to a growing number of people in prison custody in England and Wales dying of natural causes.

If their medical condition means they need treatment outside of the prison, staff have to decide whether to restrain them, either by using handcuffs or escorts chains, in order to prevent a possible escape.

These decisions affect the experience of the dying prisoner and the officers accompanying them and are frequently criticised by independent reviews after a prisoner has died.

The research

Funded by the Economic and Social Research Council, this research has looked at how deaths from natural causes in prison impact on prison regimes, culture and relationships and what determines the responses of prison regimes and personnel to dying prisoners.

Analysing the prison service's rules relating to dying prisoners revealed contradictions in how regulations were communicated to prison staff, making it less likely that their decisions would fully comply with legal requirements.

The research also found practices that were helping some prisons make better decisions about the use of restraints.

The outcome

After publishing an article about the rules of restraints on terminally ill prisoners, our researcher was consulted by the Directorate of Security, Order and Counter Terrorism to help develop the new External Hospitals Escort guide for use by prison staff.

Findings from the research are included in this operational practice guide, helping prison staff to make effective security decisions that also meet the care needs of prisoners who have treatment in a hospital outside of prison.

Featured researcher
Carol Robinson

Carol Robinson

PhD Candidate and Lecturer in Criminology

Carol is the holder of an ESRC PhD Studentship as part of the White Rose Doctoral Training Centre. Her thesis is entitled Dying inside: deaths from natural causes in prison culture, regimes and relationships.

View profile

Case studies

Read more examples of York research making a difference.

Explore case studies

Sociology

Explore more research from the Department of Sociology.

Find out more