Skip to content Accessibility statement

Expert Reaction: Should Google offer an online screening test for depression?

News

Posted on Thursday 14 September 2017

With one in five Americans experiencing clinical depression in their lifetime, should Google offer an online screening test for depression? University of York researcher, Professor Simon Gilbody, debates the issue in The British Medical Journal (BMJ).

Professor Gilbody, from the University of York’s Department of Health Sciences, said: “There are reasons to be concerned that data generated by a depression screening programme might be used to market antidepressants.

"Depression should be diagnosed following a clinical assessment rather than a one-time screening test.  Episodes of transient and self-limiting psychological distress will be confused with pervasive disorders that warrant treatment. 

“Recent disease awareness campaigns and unregulated screening programmes present risks of over-diagnosis, supplier induced demand, and inappropriate treatment. 

“Google’s initiative has been reported positively and uncritically despite bypassing the usual checks and balances that exist for good reason. It is unlikely that their initiative will improve population health and may in fact do harm.”

The full article is published in The BMJ here: http://www.bmj.com/content/358/bmj.j4144

 

Research newsletter

Our monthly research newsletter features a curated mix of news, events, and recent discoveries delivered straight to your inbox.

Sign up

Explore more news

News

9 July 2026

Nine out of 10 students at the University of York are satisfied with the academic support they receive, according to the results of the 2026 National Student Survey (NSS).

News

3 July 2026

Bears often get a bad reputation, but a new study shows that they might not be the species most often involved in human-wildlife interaction that can lead to conflicts in national parks.

News

1 July 2026

Predicting whether a company's profits will rise or fall has long been one of the most notoriously difficult tasks in finance. Corporate earnings underpin trillions of dollars in market valuation, yet traditional forecasting models are routinely upended by economic shocks, shifting consumer tastes, and unexpected corporate crises.

News

25 June 2026

The Scottish Child Payment (SCP) is successfully reducing child poverty and food insecurity, according to a new major study, featuring researchers from the University of York.

News

25 June 2026

Technological developments could change how artists connect with fans, following a trial of a virtual live performance held across two different counties.

Read more news