Discrimination against same-sex couples denied religious marriage is endemic, says York academic
Posted on Wednesday 3 May 2017
Professor Paul Johnson, from York’s Department of Sociology, has examined the legal framework in England and Wales that allows religious organisations to refuse to marry same-sex couples.
Working in collaboration with Professor Robert Vanderbeck at Leeds, Professor Johnson found that same-sex couples are excluded from approximately 40,200 places of worship in which opposite-sex couples can get married.
Same-sex couples are not permitted to marry in any of the 17,350 churches of the Church of England and the Church in Wales, or in nearly 23,000 other places of worship, such as Roman Catholic churches, Islamic mosques, and Hindu temples.
Although same-sex marriage has been legal in England and Wales since 2014, religious organisations are under no obligation to extend their marriage services to gay couples.
Opt-in decision
The Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act 2013 provides the means for organised religions – other than the Church of England – to opt in to conduct same-sex marriages, with the decision left to individual institutions.
Only 139 places of worship are registered to perform same-sex marriage in England and Wales, meaning approximately 99.5 per cent do not offer it. Just 23 same-sex couples had a religious marriage ceremony in 2014, compared with over 68,000 opposite-sex couples.
Professor Paul Johnson said: “The level of discrimination is staggering. If you are a same-sex couple in England and Wales then you most likely live in a town where there is no opportunity to have a religious marriage ceremony. That means you are completely shut out of a mainstream cultural practice that opposite-sex couples take for granted.
“Recent reports describe same-sex couples ‘shunning’ religious wedding ceremonies, but the reality is they are simply being denied the opportunity. Parliament has agreed a legislative framework for marriage that is allowing extensive discrimination, and the figures support this.”
Minor faith groups
Professor Robert Vanderbeck said: “Because none of the mainstream religious faiths will marry same-sex couples, such couples need to rely on minor faith groups, such as Unitarians, to be willing to marry them. The problem is, the couple might not share that faith.”
Church of England Canon law - which defines marriage as the ‘union of one man with one woman’ – co-exists alongside the contrary general marriage statute law allowing same-sex marriage, due to the religious protections included in the 2013 Act.
Further information
- Sacred Spaces, Sacred Words: Religion and Same-sex Marriage in England and Wales by Paul Johnson (Professor of Sociology, University of York) and Robert M. Vanderbeck (Professor of Geography, University of Leeds) is published in the summer issue of the Journal of Law and Society. To read, visit: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jols.12024/full
- Same-sex couples cannot marry in any of the 16,000 churches of the Church of England, or the 1350 churches of the Church in Wales. Of the 22,884 other places of worship that are registered to solemnize opposite-sex marriage, 22,745 do not solemnize same-sex marriage (approximately 99.5 per cent).
- There are only 139 places of worship registered to perform same-sex marriage in England and Wales, although this number does not take account of places in which same-sex marriage may be solemnized by Jews or Quakers.
- In 2014, approximately 30 per cent of opposite-sex couples who married had a religious marriage ceremony, compared with 0.5 per cent of same-sex couples.
