New research demonstrates constant productivity growth in the NHS
Posted on 30 March 2012
A new study by researchers at the Centre for Health Economics, University of York, reveals the productivity of the NHS in England has been broadly constant over the last seven years, increasing by an average of 0.1 per cent per year.
Researchers at CHE used the most detailed and
comprehensive information available to compare growth in the total amount of
resources (input) used to produce health care provided to NHS patients (output).
There has been a
constant return with NHS output increasing at the same rate as NHS inputs
Professor Andrew Street
The research shows that
between 2003/4 to 2009/10 the number of staff has increased by 18 per cent,
buildings and equipment by 24 per cent and all other inputs, such as clinical
supplies and energy costs, by 76 per cent.
There has also been a
corresponding increase in both the quantity and quality of output. The number
of patients treated in hospital increased from 12.1m to 15.6m; outpatient
attendances from 50m to 77m; community care contacts from 76m to 92m; and
primary care consultations from 262m to 300m.
Over the same period,
hospital survival rates improved from 99.4 per cent to 99.8 per cent for
elective patients and from 95 per cent to 96 per cent for non-electives. Average
inpatient waiting times fell from 78 to 57 days, reaching a low of 51 days in
2008/9. Outpatient waiting times fell from 58 days to 24 days.
All in all, growth in
activity and changes in quality have tracked the growth in inputs, implying
that productivity has been flat over the seven year period.
Professor Andrew Street,
from the University’s Centre for Health Economics, said: “There has been a big increase
in NHS inputs over the last few years, with more staff employed and updated equipment
and facilities. This has been matched by commensurate increases in the numbers
of patients being treated and in improvements in the quality of care.
“Over the last seven
years, NHS productivity growth has been flat. This means that there has been a
constant return with NHS output increasing at the same rate as NHS inputs.”
Notes to editors:
further information contact Professor Andrew Street on 01904
321401 or firstname.lastname@example.org
Bojke, Adriana Castelli, Rosalind Goudie, Andrew Street, Padraic Ward. Productivity of the English National Health
Service 2003/4-2009/10 CHE Research Paper 76, York: University of York, 2012. Visit: www.york.ac.uk/che/publications/in-house/
growth is calculated by comparing growth in the total amount of health care
‘output’ to growth in the total amount of ‘input’ used to produce this output.
‘Output’ consists of the volume of all health care services provided to all NHS
patients in England and also accounts for quality improvements, including
changes in hospital survival, health outcomes and waiting times. ‘Inputs’
include the staff, supplies, energy costs, equipment and building resources
that contribute to the production of health care.
project was funded by the Department of Health in England as part of a
programme of policy research at the Centre for Health Economics, University of
York. The views expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and
not necessarily those of the Department of Health.
Centre for Health Economics is a department of the University of York. The
Centre’s aim is to undertake high quality research that is capable of
influencing health policy decisions. The Centre is one of the largest health
economics research units in the world and its research aims to influence the
way decision makers think about the determinants of health and wellbeing, and
the organization and delivery of health and social care. Website: www.york.ac.uk/che